2026 City Journal College Rankings


Photo by ferrantraite/E+ via Getty Images

110
Overall Rank

University of Vermont

Burlington, VT
111
Rank
Faculty Ideological Pluralism
111
Rank
Quality of General Education Requirements
111
Rank
Student Ideological Pluralism

The University of Vermont was founded in 1791, the same year Vermont became America’s 14th state, making it the fifth-oldest college in New England. It was a champion of tolerance and equality from its inception, distinguishing itself as the first American institution of higher education whose charter did not give preference to any religious sect or denomination. UVM has failed to live up to those founding values. Instead, the university has zealously embraced the cause of social justice.

UVM has not adopted a policy of institutional neutrality, and it shows. Land acknowledgments, formal environmental commitments, and “gender identity” accommodations are just a few examples of the administration’s activist inclinations. The university is deeply committed to DEI: in 2024, UVM’s “outstanding commitment to academic excellence and belonging” earned it a Higher Education Excellence in Diversity (HEED) Award, a national honor reserved for institutions demonstrating a significant commitment to diversity and inclusion.

In early 2025, amid federal pressure and threats to funding, UVM began quietly scrubbing DEI terminology from its websites and rebranding DEI offices and roles under the language of “Intercultural Excellence.” These cosmetic changes have done little to alter the underlying infrastructure. The university’s identity centers—including its Mosaic Intercultural Center, the Women and Gender Equity Center (WAGE), and the LGBTQ+ Prism Center—continue to operate as before. The Comprehensive Inclusive Excellence Action Plan (IEAP), described as a “data-driven DEI strategic planning process,” remains in effect through 2028, with measurable DEI goals embedded across every academic and administrative unit.

Marlene Tromp was installed as UVM’s 28th president in September 2025. In her address, she characterized the federal and state effort to eliminate DEI initiatives in higher education as a “tidal wave of anger.” Tromp has thus far upheld the university’s record of prioritizing demographic diversity over merit: UVM continues to solicit diversity statements or comparable requirements in its faculty job advertisements and maintains an admissions policy that allows applicants to withhold standardized test scores.

Support for free speech is lacking. UVM operates a bias-response system designed to monitor and mediate speech that some may find offensive. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) awards the school an F grade for its overall speech climate and a “yellow” speech code rating, indicating that its policies may be easily abused to suppress protected expression. UVM’s “Policies on Bias and Hate Speech,” for example, encourage “any person who has experienced or witnessed discrimination, harassment, or bias involving protected identities to report the conduct to UVM’s Office of Equal Opportunity.” That said, 80 percent of students tell FIRE it is at least “somewhat” clear that the administration protects free speech on campus—almost exactly the national average.

At first glance, the student speech climate appears relatively healthy, with one of the ten lowest rates of self-censorship in our rankings. However, this apparent openness reflects ideological consensus more than genuine tolerance for disagreement. UVM students are the fifth-least pluralistic in our rankings, scoring 11.2 on a political-balance scale from 0 (“homogeneous”) to 100 (“perfect balance”).

No student organizations cater to conservative interests. Political tolerance is also low. Students are significantly biased toward left-leaning speakers and show greater-than-average support for disruptive responses to objectionable speech: 82 percent say that it is acceptable, at least in rare cases, to shout down a campus speaker. No student political organizations center conservative values or interests.

UVM has seen its share of radical activism surrounding the Israel-Gaza conflict. In March 2025, the school’s chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine—back from a temporary suspension for its role in UVM’s 2024 pro-Palestinian student encampment—announced a “Week of Rage,” with daily events protesting the war in Gaza. Organizers framed the events as “building our collective strength against the death machine of U.S. empire.” At rallies, protesters displayed signs reading “Resistance is justified when people are occupied.” The administration has taken small steps to protect Jewish students, but none of the antisemitic agitators involved in these events has faced expulsion, according to public reports.

The faculty is also politically skewed. On a scale of 1 (“very liberal”) to 7 (“very conservative”), students place UVM professors at 2.3 on average. Campaign-finance show that 100 percent of faculty donors reliably contribute to liberal candidates and causes. UVM’s professoriate ranks among the 25 least politically extreme, and it has a relatively high rate of faculty membership in Heterodox Academy, an organization that promotes viewpoint diversity in the classroom.

UVM ranks among our bottom 10 schools for overall educational experience, placing 108th for faculty teaching quality and 111th for general education requirements. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) gives the school an F in its What Will They Learn? ratings, which assign letter grades based on how many of seven core subjects are required in the core curriculum or general education program. DEI coursework is mandatory, but U.S. history and government are not. Faculty composition reflects similar priorities: identity-studies faculty outnumber history faculty by 3.7 to one, compared with a benchmark of 1.7 to one.

The university delivers weak academic returns. Six-year graduation and retention rates are below average and fall short of expectations based on students’ SAT scores and Pell Grant eligibility. Median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment reach $62,500—roughly $18,500 below the norm and about $12,700 less than predicted. Graduates typically take 3.6 years to recoup their educational investment, compared with our 2.5-year benchmark. Compounding these shortcomings, UVM faces a $12 million structural deficit driven by declining undergraduate enrollment.

Overall Weighted Score: 29.57 / 100

Factors
Score
Rank
Educational Quality
3.90 / 30
#110
Faculty Ideological Pluralism
0.42 / 2
#111
Faculty Teaching Quality
0.19 / 1
#108
Faculty Research Quality
0.37 / 1
#74
Faculty Speech Climate
0.92 / 1
#76
Quality of General Education Requirements
0.00 / 6
#111
Heterodox Infrastructure
0.50 / 15
#60
Traditional History Curriculum
0.38 / 2
#37
Faculty Political Restraint
1.00 / 1
#25
Faculty Heterodox Memberships
0.11 / 1
#65
Governance Quality
7.68 / 20
#94
Commitment to Meritocracy
4.20 / 10
#85
Support for Free Speech
0.89 / 3
#82
Resistance to Politicization
0.25 / 2
#89
Administrative Ideological Pluralism
0.11 / 1
#79
Independence From Malign Foreign Influence
0.99 / 1
#45
Presidential Rhetorical Leadership
1.24 / 3
#61
Outcomes
13.65 / 40
#107
Quality of Alumni Network
0.00 / 1
#29
Payback Education Investment
6.32 / 13
#96
Value Added to Career
4.09 / 16
#107
Value Added to Education
3.23 / 10
#107
Student Life
3.35 / 10
#98
Student Ideological Pluralism
0.38 / 4
#111
Student Freedom to Speak
0.68 / 1
#7
Student Political Tolerance
0.55 / 1
#108
Student Social Life
0.15 / 1
#40
Student Political Restraint
0.83 / 1
#59
ROTC Participation
0.27 / 1
#66
Student Community Life
0.50 / 1
#57