2026 City Journal College Rankings


Photo by ferrantraite/E+ via Getty Images

114
Overall Rank

Smith College

Northampton, MA
115
Rank
Student Ideological Pluralism
115
Rank
Value Added to Career
113
Rank
Payback Education Investment

Smith College is a private women’s liberal arts school located in Northampton, Massachusetts. One of the historic Seven Sisters colleges, it positions itself as a leader in feminism and social justice. Yet Smith fails to fulfill its most fundamental obligations: cultivating independent, critical thinkers and preparing students for professional and financial success.

Smith’s student body is the most ideologically skewed in our rankings, with a score of just 0.6 on a political-balance scale from 0 (“homogeneous”) to 100 (“perfect balance”). No student political organizations center conservative or Right-wing interests. Students are significantly less tolerant of opposing political views than are most of their peers. The college encourages them to be “the loud voices that inspire change,” and many take that directive literally: according to the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), 88 percent say it’s acceptable to shout down a speaker, at least in rare cases, and 58 percent say the same about blocking other students from attending a campus speech. Thirty-eight percent say violence can be an acceptable response to speech, slightly higher than the national average.

The faculty at Smith also skews left. Students give their professors an average rating of 2.2 on FIRE’s seven-point ideological continuum, where 1 is “very liberal” and 7 is “very conservative.” Campaign-finance data show that less than 1.8 percent of faculty donors reliably contribute to conservative candidates and causes. Teaching quality is a relative strength: 99 percent of Smith students surveyed by Niche say their professors are passionate about the topics they teach and eager to help.

The administration’s support for free speech is limited. Only 17 percent of Smith students tell the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) that the college would be “very” likely to defend a speaker’s right to express his views on campus in the event of a controversy over offensive speech; no students say it would be “extremely” likely. Smith endorses the Chicago Principles, affirming at least a nominal commitment to protecting open inquiry on campus, but also operates a Bias Response Team that polices speech that some may find offensive—an Orwellian practice that can chill student discourse. FIRE gives Smith a “red” speech code rating, indicating that its policies clearly and substantially restrict protected speech.

Smith has subordinated merit to racial and demographic diversity. In 2022, the college signed an amicus brief supporting race-conscious admissions in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard, the Supreme Court case that effectively ended affirmative action in higher education. Smith does not require applicants to submit standardized test scores during the admissions process. Despite formally limiting the use of diversity statements in faculty hiring, the college’s job advertisements suggest that such requirements persist.

The college has not embraced institutional neutrality, and administrative activism is pervasive at Smith—as evidenced by multiple environmental pledges and a school-wide land acknowledgment. Smith’s devotion to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) has earned it the Higher Education Excellence in Diversity (HEED) Award for three consecutive years, from 2022 through 2024. Despite the federal campaign to end race-conscious programs in higher education, Smith’s DEI infrastructure remains largely intact, including a central DEI office. The college is still committed to its 2020 Toward Racial Justice action plan, which urges Smith to require equity and inclusion training for faculty and staff; make Juneteenth a “day of learning for white and non-Black staff and faculty”; provide staff with “paid time to participate in inclusion- and identity-focused programming”; and tie DEI more closely to “incentive and compensation structures,” among other recommendations.

Anti-Semitism is pervasive at Smith. The AMCHA Initiative documents 136 reported anti-Semitic incidents per 1,000 Jewish undergraduates, compared with our average of 85.6. The college also has one of the highest concentrations of anti-Zionist student organizations in our rankings, along with a significant number of anti-Zionist faculty. The problem has escalated since Hamas’s October 7, 2023, terrorist attack on Israel, which sparked a wave of anti-Israel protests across American higher education. In spring 2024, 50 members of Smith’s Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) chapter occupied College Hall for nearly two weeks, demanding divestment from companies supporting Israel. In response, the administration adopted a revised time-and-place policy governing student demonstrations, restricting practices like concealing identities with face coverings and entering closed buildings. Disruptive protests nevertheless continued, including another encampment in spring 2026—dubbed the “People’s University”—during which student activists circulated a petition accusing Israel of committing “femi-genocide,” among other charges. The petition accumulated more than 500 signatures and support from 56 campus organizations. No students involved in any of these protests appear to have been disciplined by the college.

Though Smith calls itself a women’s college, it has technically been coeducational for over a decade: “self-identified transgender women”—men who claim to be women—and “nonbinary” applicants have been admitted since 2015. Transgender men—women, that is—are not eligible for Smith’s undergraduate programs. In May 2026, the U.S. Department of Education opened a Title IX investigation into the school’s “gender self-identification” policy,

Smith’s “open curriculum” offers little structure. Its sole requirement is an introductory writing course, which can be satisfied through seminars such as “#FlipTheScript: Hot Topics in African Feminism(s) Today,” “Gender, Race, Sexuality and Empire,” and “Borders, Identity, and Justice.” The history department’s offerings lean left: for every course description that references the traditional canon, 5.7 use progressive terminology, above our 4.4 average Smith’s history faculty pursue research related to critical theory concepts at twice the average rate, and identity studies scholars outnumber historians six to one. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) gives the college an F in its What Will They Learn? ratings, which assign letter grades based on how many of seven core subjects are required in the core curriculum or general education program.

We rank Smith second-to-last on our measures of student outcomes. Six-year graduation and retention rates are roughly average but fall short of expectations based on students’ SAT scores and Pell Grant eligibility. The cost of attendance exceeds $100,000 annually, placing Smith among the most expensive colleges in the country. Meanwhile, the financial returns are exceptionally weak: median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment are roughly $64,000—about $17,000 below the norm and more than $24,400 less than predicted. Graduates typically take six years to recoup their educational investment, more than twice our 2.5-year average.

Smith’s “unwavering commitment” to “women’s rights” may be well-intentioned. But what about a woman’s right to a rigorous education? With few academic requirements, minimal exposure to dissenting opinions, and an administration reluctant to enforce standards of conduct, the college fails to prepare its students for life after graduation—and enfeebles the women whom it claims to empower.

Overall Weighted Score: 26.04 / 100

Factors
Score
Rank
Educational Quality
6.68 / 30
#69
Faculty Ideological Pluralism
0.45 / 2
#109
Faculty Teaching Quality
0.57 / 1
#7
Faculty Research Quality
0.16 / 1
#100
Faculty Speech Climate
1.00 / 1
#1
Quality of General Education Requirements
3.30 / 6
#45
Heterodox Infrastructure
0.00 / 15
#70
Traditional History Curriculum
0.24 / 2
#109
Faculty Political Restraint
0.79 / 1
#87
Faculty Heterodox Memberships
0.16 / 1
#49
Governance Quality
8.78 / 20
#81
Commitment to Meritocracy
4.45 / 10
#80
Support for Free Speech
1.32 / 3
#55
Resistance to Politicization
0.25 / 2
#89
Administrative Ideological Pluralism
0.00 / 1
#115
Independence From Malign Foreign Influence
1.00 / 1
#1
Presidential Rhetorical Leadership
1.76 / 3
#24
Outcomes
6.77 / 40
#114
Quality of Alumni Network
0.00 / 1
#29
Payback Education Investment
1.66 / 13
#113
Value Added to Career
0.29 / 16
#115
Value Added to Education
4.81 / 10
#84
Student Life
2.93 / 10
#111
Student Ideological Pluralism
0.02 / 4
#115
Student Freedom to Speak
0.67 / 1
#10
Student Political Tolerance
0.42 / 1
#115
Student Social Life
0.30 / 1
#10
Student Political Restraint
0.97 / 1
#31
ROTC Participation
0.02 / 1
#104
Student Community Life
0.53 / 1
#49