2026 City Journal College Rankings


Photo by ferrantraite/E+ via Getty Images

87
Overall Rank

Kenyon College

Gambier, OH
107
Rank
Payback Education Investment
106
Rank
Value Added to Education
95
Rank
Faculty Ideological Pluralism

Kenyon College embraces some of the worst trends in higher education. Its administration has not adopted institutional neutrality, leaving the college vulnerable to politicization. Administrative activism takes many forms, from environmental pledges to land acknowledgments. Racial and demographic diversity outrank merit: Kenyon does not require applicants to submit standardized test scores, and its faculty job advertisements contain evidence of diversity requirements—both signs that identity takes precedence over ability.

Kenyon’s commitment to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) has not diminished under federal pressure, and its central DEI office remains fully intact. Among its many functions, the office oversees recruitment and retention, affinity housing and student groups, and college-wide educational programming on “cultures, identities and social justice movements.” It also offers training and resources to help faculty incorporate DEI principles into their teaching. For example, a guide titled “Allyship in the Classroom” encourages professors to “avoid heteronormative and cisnormative practices,” adopt “culturally responsive pedagogy,” and emphasize equity for students with “marginalized identities”—because “being treated equally is not enough to create safe, inclusive spaces.”

A network of student identity centers offers additional “multicultural programming,” from sex education to “Alumni of Color Mentoring,” along with specialized resources for students and faculty with various identities. “Trans at Kenyon,” for example, offers “binding” and “tucking” tips and helps students access a “Student Success Fund” that covers “trans related apparel” and fees associated with “the name and/or gender marker change process.” These centers employ 2.3 staff members per 1,000 undergraduates, compared with our average of 1.5.

Kenyon ranks in our top 20 for its support of free speech. The administration endorses the Chicago Principles, which affirm the importance of open inquiry in higher education. Yet students lack confidence in the school’s commitment to those principles: according to the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), only 17 percent of students believe that Kenyon would be “very” or “extremely” likely to defend a speaker’s right to express offensive views on campus in the event of a controversy, compared with 24 percent nationally. FIRE gives the college a “yellow” speech-code rating, indicating that its policies are vague or could easily be misused to suppress speech.

The student body is relatively pluralistic, scoring 42.8 on a political-balance scale from 0 (“homogeneous”) to 100 (“perfect balance”). No student political organizations center conservative interests. Self-censorship is also common on campus: 67 percent of Kenyon students tell FIRE that they censor themselves at least once a month, compared with 59 percent nationally. Tolerance for opposing political views is limited, and Kenyon students are far more receptive to controversial speakers on the Left than to those on the Right. Only 31 percent say it is never acceptable to shout down a campus speaker, while 73 percent reject violence as an acceptable response to speech, compared with 66 percent nationally.

Kenyon’s faculty lacks ideological diversity. When asked to place their professors on a political continuum, where 1 is “very liberal” and 7 is “very conservative,” students give them an average score of 2.6. Campaign finance records also reveal a liberal bias, with only 1.8 percent of faculty donors reliably contributing to conservative candidates or causes. Very few faculty belong to organizations that support open inquiry and viewpoint diversity in higher education.

The curriculum falls short. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) gives Kenyon an F in its What Will They Learn? ratings, which assign letter grades based on how many of seven core subjects are required in the core curriculum or general education program. The college does not mandate foundational subjects such as U.S. history or government, though it also imposes no DEI-related coursework requirements. A quarter of the history faculty pursue research related to critical theory concepts, and the department’s course offerings skew left: for every course description that references the traditional canon, 3.9 use progressive terminology.

Kenyon’s Department of Political Science offers the “Quest for Justice” course, which provides a non-ideological introduction to the Western intellectual tradition.

Kenyon does not deliver strong academic or financial outcomes. Six-year graduation and retention rates are both below average and fall short of predictions based on students’ SAT scores and Pell Grant eligibility. Median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment fall roughly $9,200 below the benchmark and slightly underperform expectations. Graduates typically take 4.5 years to recoup the cost of attendance, two years longer than average.

Overall Weighted Score: 41.09 / 100

Factors
Score
Rank
Educational Quality
8.29 / 30
#47
Faculty Ideological Pluralism
0.57 / 2
#95
Faculty Teaching Quality
0.32 / 1
#29
Faculty Research Quality
0.13 / 1
#108
Faculty Speech Climate
1.00 / 1
#1
Quality of General Education Requirements
3.30 / 6
#45
Heterodox Infrastructure
1.50 / 15
#47
Traditional History Curriculum
0.33 / 2
#59
Faculty Political Restraint
1.00 / 1
#30
Faculty Heterodox Memberships
0.14 / 1
#55
Governance Quality
9.97 / 20
#56
Commitment to Meritocracy
4.66 / 10
#78
Support for Free Speech
2.12 / 3
#19
Resistance to Politicization
0.35 / 2
#64
Administrative Ideological Pluralism
0.24 / 1
#43
Independence From Malign Foreign Influence
1.00 / 1
#1
Presidential Rhetorical Leadership
1.59 / 3
#32
Outcomes
15.34 / 40
#103
Quality of Alumni Network
0.00 / 1
#29
Payback Education Investment
4.60 / 13
#107
Value Added to Career
7.39 / 16
#67
Value Added to Education
3.35 / 10
#106
Student Life
4.08 / 10
#69
Student Ideological Pluralism
1.46 / 4
#50
Student Freedom to Speak
0.58 / 1
#93
Student Political Tolerance
0.64 / 1
#67
Student Social Life
0.00 / 1
#65
Student Political Restraint
0.99 / 1
#15
ROTC Participation
0.00 / 1
#108
Student Community Life
0.41 / 1
#79