2026 City Journal College Rankings


Photo by ferrantraite/E+ via Getty Images

88
Overall Rank

Gettysburg College

Gettysburg, PA
105
Rank
Quality of General Education Requirements

Gettysburg College is located beside the Civil War battlefield where Abraham Lincoln delivered the Gettysburg Address, reaffirming America’s founding ideals. The college has lost sight of its own founding mission, instead prioritizing ideology over education.

The administration skews heavily left. Campaign-finance records show that 100 percent of administrative donors reliably contribute to liberal candidates or causes. Gettysburg has not adopted institutional neutrality, as evidenced by its official land acknowledgment, formal environmental commitments, and other forms of political posturing. The college has a record of putting demographic diversity ahead of merit: it has a test-optional admissions policy, and its faculty job advertisements contain evidence of diversity requirements.

The school’s Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) infrastructure remains intact, despite federal pressure to scale back such programming, and Gettysburg president Bob Iuliano has pledged to defend the college’s “values and programs” if they come under federal investigation. The Office of Diversity & Inclusion, led by a chief diversity officer, continues to “address the intersections and multiplicities of identities” and “enhance . . . intercultural awareness” through “anti-racism” and anti-bias trainings, faculty mentoring in “inclusive pedagogy,” a Land Acknowledgement Committee, and “a robust slate of speakers and campus-based conversations,” among other efforts.

The Office of Multicultural Engagement provides “one-on-one mentorship for first-year students of color,” “social justice” programming, affinity groups, and other resources for “historically underrepresented student groups, while the Gender and Sexuality Resource Center offers advocacy, a student fund, gender-inclusive bathrooms and housing, and a “gender-affirming clothing closet” stocked with items including “chest binders.” In addition, individual academic departments and administrative units publish their own DEI statements and develop strategic plans to advance diversity.

Gettysburg’s record on free speech is poor. According to the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), 71 percent believe that, if a controversy arose over offensive speech, the college would be at least somewhat likely to defend speakers’ right to express their views on campus. Gettysburg has endorsed the Chicago Principles, which affirm open inquiry and expression. However, it also operates a bias-reporting system—a practice that can chill open discourse. FIRE gives the school a “yellow” speech-code rating, indicating that its policies could be misused to suppress speech.

The faculty skews heavily leftward. When asked to rate their professors on an ideological continuum from 1 (“very liberal”) to 7 (“very conservative”), Gettysburg students give them an average score of 2.8. Campaign-finance records show that 100 percent of faculty donors reliably contribute to liberal candidates or causes. No professors belong to the Academic Freedom Alliance, and only 1 percent are members of the Heterodox Academy—organizations that promote academic freedom and viewpoint diversity in higher education. In addition, 1.5 per 100 faculty members publicly support academic boycotts of Israel—a relatively high rate for our rankings.

The student body falls in the upper quartile of our rankings for ideological pluralism. On a political balance scale from 0 (“homogeneous”) to 100 (“perfect balance”), Gettysburg scores 45.6. Students report being tolerant of opposing political views and relatively evenhanded in their attitudes toward controversial speakers on the Left and Right. Self-censorship is nevertheless pervasive on campus: 65 percent of Gettysburg students say they censor themselves in conversation with peers at least once a month, compared with 59 percent of students nationally, and 67 percent say they censor themselves in conversation with their professors, versus 61 percent nationally.

Gettysburg has experienced an elevated rate of student-led deplatforming attempts since 2021. Support for disruptive protest tactics is near the national average: 70 percent of students consider shouting down a speaker acceptable, at least in rare cases, and 53 percent say the same about blocking other students from attending a campus speech. Thirty-one percent say that violence can be an acceptable response to speech, compared with 34 percent nationally.

The college ranks sixth overall for student community life, with 75 student organizations per 1,000 undergraduates—one of the highest rates. It also has a dense concentration of academically focused groups and organizations centered on spirituality or religion. Gettysburg students lead a chapter of BridgeUSA, which promotes civil discourse and constructive engagement across political differences. There are no anti-Zionist student organizations on campus.

The curriculum needs serious reform. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) gives Gettysburg an F in its What Will They Learn? ratings, which assess how many of seven core subjects students must study to graduate. Foundational subjects like U.S. history or government are not required, while students must complete two “Cultural Diversity” courses on “peoples who have historically been underrepresented in the curriculum and/or on . . . the construction of social identity.” Twenty-two percent of the history faculty pursue research related to critical theory concepts, compared with an average of 34 percent. Even so, history course descriptions that use progressive terminology outnumber those that reference the traditional canon by 3.1 to 1.

Gettysburg can be a risky investment. Six-year graduation and retention rates are below average, though both exceed expectations based on student SAT scores and Pell Grant eligibility. Financial returns, however, are disappointing. Median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment are approximately $71,500—roughly $9,500 below the norm and more than $2,800 short of the predicted income. Graduates typically take 3.3 years to recoup the cost of their education, nearly a year longer than average.

Overall Weighted Score: 40.78 / 100

Factors
Score
Rank
Educational Quality
4.03 / 30
#108
Faculty Ideological Pluralism
0.60 / 2
#83
Faculty Teaching Quality
0.48 / 1
#16
Faculty Research Quality
0.00 / 1
#115
Faculty Speech Climate
1.00 / 1
#1
Quality of General Education Requirements
0.50 / 6
#105
Heterodox Infrastructure
0.00 / 15
#70
Traditional History Curriculum
0.38 / 2
#41
Faculty Political Restraint
0.99 / 1
#48
Faculty Heterodox Memberships
0.08 / 1
#80
Governance Quality
9.04 / 20
#72
Commitment to Meritocracy
4.70 / 10
#75
Support for Free Speech
1.81 / 3
#34
Resistance to Politicization
0.25 / 2
#89
Administrative Ideological Pluralism
0.05 / 1
#100
Independence From Malign Foreign Influence
1.00 / 1
#1
Presidential Rhetorical Leadership
1.24 / 3
#61
Outcomes
19.52 / 40
#76
Quality of Alumni Network
0.00 / 1
#29
Payback Education Investment
6.73 / 13
#91
Value Added to Career
7.68 / 16
#60
Value Added to Education
5.11 / 10
#81
Student Life
5.36 / 10
#28
Student Ideological Pluralism
2.00 / 4
#26
Student Freedom to Speak
0.58 / 1
#92
Student Political Tolerance
0.68 / 1
#39
Student Social Life
0.00 / 1
#65
Student Political Restraint
0.89 / 1
#36
ROTC Participation
0.32 / 1
#58
Student Community Life
0.90 / 1
#6