Davidson College
Davidson College promotes itself as one of the most selective and affordable colleges in the United States. While that may be true, it doesn’t make Davidson a great school, given its activist administration and weak support for free speech on campus.
The administration is among the least ideologically diverse in our rankings. Campaign-finance records show that 100 percent of administrators’ political contributions reliably flow toward liberal candidates or causes. Davidson has not adopted institutional neutrality, and its administration has a record of politicization, including the college’s multiple environmental commitments.
Davidson has persistently put racial diversity ahead of merit. The college filed an amicus brief supporting affirmative action in the Students for Fair Admissions case at the Supreme Court. Davidson’s own admissions process is “test-optional,” and its faculty job advertisements contain evidence of diversity requirements. Unlike many peer schools, Davidson has largely resisted pressure from the federal government to end race-conscious Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) practices. Its central DEI office, led by a chief diversity officer, continues to partner with offices across the college “to uplift the intersections of culture and identity” and “offers specific programming and support to . . . students of color, LGBTQIA+ students, undocumented students,” and other identity groups. Its many initiatives include “gender inclusive housing.”
The administration has a decent record on free expression, compared with its peers at other institutions. Students have more confidence in the administration’s commitment to protecting free speech than their peers at most schools we studied: 77 percent tell the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) that, in a controversy over offensive speech, the college would be at least somewhat likely to defend a speaker’s right to share her views on campus. While Davidson has adopted the Chicago Principles, which promote free inquiry, it also operates a bias-response system that polices speech some may find offensive—a practice that can chill student discourse. FIRE gives the college a “yellow” speech-code rating, indicating that its policies can easily be misused to restrict expression.
The faculty at Davidson lack ideological diversity. Asked to place their professors on a 7-point continuum, where 1 is “very liberal” and 7 is “very conservative,” students place them at 2.5, on average. Only 3.6 percent of faculty who donate to political campaigns reliably contribute to conservative candidates or causes. About 1.7 percent of the faculty—a relatively large share compared with most schools in our rankings—belongs to Heterodox Academy, which promotes pluralism in the classroom. Students generally have a favorable view of their instructors. Davidson places in the upper quartile of our rankings for faculty teaching quality, with 95 percent of students surveyed by Niche reporting that their professors are engaging, easy to understand, and passionate about the topics they teach. For every 100 faculty members, 0.4 publicly support academic boycotts of Israel, compared with an average of 1.9.
Davidson students are among the 25 most pluralistic in our rankings. On a political balance scale from 0 (“homogeneous”) to 100 (“perfect balance”), the student body scores 43.3. The composition of student political organizations is perfectly balanced, with an equal number of liberal and conservative groups. At the same time, self-censorship is rampant among Davidson students, who are substantially more fearful than many of their peers of negative reactions to their opinions. They are also more likely than average to hide their views from professors out of concern for their grades.
Political tolerance is middling, though students are more evenhanded than average in their lack of receptiveness to controversial speech on both the Left and the Right. Support for disruptive protest is slightly lower than average: 65 percent of students tell FIRE it is acceptable to shout down a speaker, at least in rare cases, and 48 percent say the same about blocking other students from attending a campus speech. Only 26 percent say that violence can be an acceptable response to speech.
Anti-Semitism is a concern at Davidson. According to the AMCHA Initiative, the college has a rate of reported anti-Semitic incidents per 1,000 Jewish undergraduates about 1.3 times the average. Davidson has 111.8 student organizations per 1,000 undergraduates, compared with an average of 64.2. The rates of student organizations focused on academics and on spirituality and religion are also higher than average, while the number of anti-Zionist groups is below the norm.
Davidson’s educational program is weak. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) gives the college a B in its What Will They Learn? ratings, which assign letter grades based on how many of seven core subjects are required in the core curriculum or general education program. On our metrics, however, the picture is worse. Students may graduate without taking a single course in U.S. history or government but must complete DEI-related courses. The college falls among the bottom ten schools in our rankings for quality of U.S. history education, and 56.3 percent of its history professors pursue research related to critical theory concepts. History course descriptions that use progressive terminology outnumber those that reference the traditional canon 6.9 to 1, compared with an average of 4.4 to 1. One bright spot is the Deliberative Citizenship Initiative, which trains students and faculty in constructive dialogue and brings participants with differing views together to discuss contentious political and social issues.
The college delivers relatively strong financial returns. Six-year graduation and retention rates are slightly higher than average and exceed predictions based on student SAT scores and Pell Grant eligibility. Median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment are in line with the average and surpass expectations by roughly $2,900. Graduates typically take 1.7 years to recoup the cost of their educational investment, compared with our average repayment period of 2.5 years.