2026 City Journal College Rankings


Photo by ferrantraite/E+ via Getty Images

110
Overall Rank

Colorado College

Colorado Springs, CO
111
Rank
Commitment to Meritocracy
111
Rank
Quality of General Education Requirements
108
Rank
Payback Education Investment

Colorado College was founded in 1874, two years before Colorado became a state. Like many private liberal arts colleges, however, its distinguished history has been tarnished by the negative trends sweeping higher education.

The administration exhibits a clear liberal bias, but less so than at many peer schools. Campaign-finance data show that more than 7 percent of administrators’ political contributions flow to conservative candidates or causes, compared with an average of 5 percent. Still, Colorado College has not adopted institutional neutrality, and activism is evident: its administration embraces numerous causes that distract from its educational responsibilities, including environmental pledges and land acknowledgements. The college also ranks fifth-to-last for its commitment to meritocracy: applicants are not required to submit standardized test scores, and some faculty job advertisements include diversity requirements—strong evidence that the Colorado puts demographic diversity ahead of merit.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) plays a prominent role at the college. Colorado is a three-time winner of the Higher Education Excellence in Diversity (HEED) Award—an ignominious distinction, but one the school proudly touts. Despite significant federal pressure, its DEI infrastructure remains fully intact, and its student identity centers employ nine staff members per 1,000 undergraduates—the second highest rate in our rankings. Colorado’s central DEI office—the Office of Institutional Equity and Belonging—is led by a chief diversity officer and envisions a “justice-centered Colorado College community” that “continuously uproot[s] oppression wherever it exists, including within ourselves.” Among other functions, the office runs an Antiracist Book Club, funds DEI programming, and subsidizes campus events that promote “equity and justice.” Its strategic plan chronicles an antiracism campaign spanning hiring, curricula, funding, policy, and staff training. In 2023, the college also created the Healing and Affirming Village and Empowerment Network (HAVEN), a “safe-haven initiative” for students transferring from states with anti-DEI laws.

Colorado College has a weak record on free speech. According to the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), only 25 percent of students believe that, in a controversy over offensive speech, the administration would be “very” or “extremely” likely to defend the speaker’s right to express their views on campus. Colorado College operates a Bias Response Team that assesses the “community impact” of bias-related incidents—an Orwellian practice that can chill student discourse. FIRE gives the college a “yellow” speech-code rating, indicating that its policies could easily be misused to suppress speech.

Viewpoint diversity is lacking among students at Colorado College. The student body scores just 8.4 on a political-balance scale from 0 (“homogeneous”) to 100 (“perfectly balanced”)—among the ten lowest scores in our rankings. Self-censorship is less prevalent than at many peer schools, though this likely reflects ideological homogeneity rather than openness to dissent. Political tolerance is low, and Colorado students are significantly more receptive to controversial speakers on the Left than on the Right. However, they are less supportive of disruptive protest tactics than most of their peers: 52 percent say it is never acceptable to block others from attending a campus speech, and 83 percent reject violence in response to speech, compared with national averages of 46 percent and 66 percent, respectively.

The faculty also lacks ideological diversity. When asked to rate their professors on a scale from 1 (“very liberal”) to 7 (“very conservative”), students give them an average score of 2.4. According to campaign-finance records, only 3.5 percent of faculty donors reliably contribute to conservative candidates or causes. No faculty members belong to the Academic Freedom Alliance or Heterodox Academy, organizations that promote open inquiry and viewpoint diversity in higher education.

Anti-Israel extremism is a notable problem. Colorado College has one of the highest concentrations of anti-Zionist student organizations in our rankings—1.5 groups per 1,000 undergraduates, compared with an average of 0.7. Nearly 2 per 100 faculty members publicly support an Academic Boycott of Israel, and at least one academic department—Feminist & Gender Studies—has co-signed a Palestinian solidarity statement condemning the “settler colonialism” of Israel and the United States.

The curriculum at Colorado College is abysmal. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) gives the school an F in its What Will They Learn? ratings, which assign letter grades based on how many of seven core subjects a school requires. Students are not required to study foundational subjects such as U.S. history or government, but they are required to complete courses in “Equity and Power.” The college ranks in the top 10 for the quality of its U.S. history offerings, which are relatively balanced: for every course description that references the traditionalcanon, just 1.3 use progressive terminology, compared with an average of 4.4. However, identity-studies professors outnumber history professors by roughly 1.6 to one.

Despite decent academic outcomes, Colorado College is a poor financial investment. Six-year graduation and retention rates—87 percent and 93 percent, respectively—are in line with their benchmarks and exceed expectations based on students’ SAT scores and Pell Grant eligibility. Financial returns are exceptionally weak: median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment reach approximately $65,200—roughly $15,800 below the benchmark and more than $12,800 lower than predicted. Graduates typically take 4.9 years to recoup the cost of their education, nearly twice the 2.5-year average.

Overall Weighted Score: 29.55 / 100

Factors
Score
Rank
Educational Quality
3.31 / 30
#113
Faculty Ideological Pluralism
0.59 / 2
#86
Faculty Teaching Quality
0.30 / 1
#39
Faculty Research Quality
0.00 / 1
#114
Faculty Speech Climate
1.00 / 1
#1
Quality of General Education Requirements
0.00 / 6
#111
Heterodox Infrastructure
0.00 / 15
#70
Traditional History Curriculum
0.63 / 2
#7
Faculty Political Restraint
0.79 / 1
#88
Faculty Heterodox Memberships
0.00 / 1
#113
Governance Quality
6.92 / 20
#107
Commitment to Meritocracy
3.05 / 10
#111
Support for Free Speech
1.07 / 3
#63
Resistance to Politicization
0.25 / 2
#89
Administrative Ideological Pluralism
0.31 / 1
#27
Independence From Malign Foreign Influence
1.00 / 1
#1
Presidential Rhetorical Leadership
1.24 / 3
#61
Outcomes
15.11 / 40
#104
Quality of Alumni Network
0.00 / 1
#29
Payback Education Investment
3.84 / 13
#108
Value Added to Career
4.26 / 16
#106
Value Added to Education
7.00 / 10
#16
Student Life
3.47 / 10
#95
Student Ideological Pluralism
0.89 / 4
#89
Student Freedom to Speak
0.63 / 1
#31
Student Political Tolerance
0.59 / 1
#101
Student Social Life
0.00 / 1
#65
Student Political Restraint
0.87 / 1
#38
ROTC Participation
0.04 / 1
#96
Student Community Life
0.46 / 1
#71