2026 City Journal College Rankings


Photo by ferrantraite/E+ via Getty Images

51
Overall Rank

Catholic University of America

Washington, DC
2
Rank
Faculty Ideological Pluralism
4
Rank
Traditional History Curriculum
99
Rank
Payback Education Investment
97
Rank
Support for Free Speech

The Catholic University of America (CUA), a private research university located in Washington, D.C., aims to “preserve and impart the truth in all its forms.” Despite its laudable mission, the university has embraced many of the worst trends in higher education.

The administration is more pluralistic than most of its peers. Campaign-finance records show that 19 percent of administrative donors reliably contribute to conservative candidates or causes—a high share in our rankings. Still, CUA has not adopted institutional neutrality, and its administration is not without activist impulses: according to the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), the university has seen an elevated rate of administrator-led deplatforming attempts in recent years.

CUA has a record of putting demographic diversity ahead of merit. The university filed an amicus brief supporting affirmative action in the Students for Fair Admissions case at the Supreme Court. Its own admissions policy is test-optional. CUA does not have a central Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) office and currently employs no identity-center staff. However, the university advances diversity through its Sister Thea Bowman Committee, Center for Cultural Engagement, and various school-level initiatives.

The university has a poor record on free speech. CUA does not maintain a bias-reporting system, a practice that can chill open discourse on campus. Yet its administration has not endorsed the Chicago Principles, which affirm the importance of open inquiry and expression in higher education. The administration has also restricted student-sponsored speech. In 2026, CUA blocked two Students Supporting Israel events, including one on anti-Semitism, because the events would not feature “speakers representing both sides” of the issue. The student group had faced pushback before: On October 7, 2025, administrators dismantled its memorial to victims of Hamas’s terrorist attack against Israel two years earlier. The university said the memorial, consisting of hundreds of Israeli flags, violated a campus ban on foreign banners. Students, however, alleged that CUA had created the policy and applied it to the memorial after previously allowing Ukrainian and Palestinian banners on campus.

The faculty is more ideologically diverse than at many of the schools we studied, though it still leans left. Campaign-finance data show that 24 percent of faculty donors reliably contribute to conservative candidates or causes—the highest share in our rankings. Approximately 2.6 percent of faculty members belong to Heterodox Academy, which promotes open inquiry and intellectual pluralism in the classroom—a relatively high share in our rankings. Faculty political extremism is lower at CUA than at most peer schools, though scholars have been targeted more often than average. No faculty members publicly support academic boycotts of Israel, and no academic departments have committed themselves to anti-Zionism.

Student political extremism is a problem at CUA. According to FIRE, the rate of student-led deplatforming attempts per 1,000 undergraduates in recent years has been nearly four times the average. Student community life is solid, overall. There are 81.2 student organizations per 1,000 undergraduates, exceeding our average of 64.2. The campus ROTC program is the thirteenth strong in our rankings, with an enrollment rate of 4.2 students per 1,000 undergraduates—more than twice the average.

The curriculum performs moderately well on our metrics. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) gives CUA a C in its What Will They Learn? ratings, which assign letter grades based on how many of seven core subjects are required in the core curriculum or general education program. Though students may graduate without studying foundational subjects like U.S. history or government, they are not required to complete DEI-related coursework, either. The quality of U.S. history education is relatively impressive, earning fourth place in our rankings. Approximately 4 percent of history faculty specialize in America’s Founding era—one percentage point below the overall average. None of CUA’s history faculty, however, pursue research related to critical theory concepts, and the university has no identity-studies professors. Its history course descriptions also strike an even balance between those using progressive terminology and those referencing the traditional canon, compared with an average ratio of 4.4 to 1.

CUA delivers lackluster academic and economic outcomes. Six-year graduation and retention rates are below average, and the latter falls short of predictions based on student SAT scores and Pell Grant eligibility. Median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment are below the norm and slightly underperform expectations. Graduates typically take 3.6 years to recoup the cost of their education, more than a year longer than our average repayment period.

Overall Weighted Score: 51.69 / 100

Factors
Score
Rank
Educational Quality
9.19 / 30
#39
Faculty Ideological Pluralism
1.41 / 2
#2
Faculty Teaching Quality
0.28 / 1
#51
Faculty Research Quality
0.30 / 1
#81
Faculty Speech Climate
0.79 / 1
#95
Quality of General Education Requirements
4.35 / 6
#24
Heterodox Infrastructure
0.00 / 15
#70
Traditional History Curriculum
0.86 / 2
#4
Faculty Political Restraint
1.00 / 1
#1
Faculty Heterodox Memberships
0.20 / 1
#41
Governance Quality
10.47 / 20
#48
Commitment to Meritocracy
6.00 / 10
#42
Support for Free Speech
0.78 / 3
#97
Resistance to Politicization
0.49 / 2
#54
Administrative Ideological Pluralism
0.78 / 1
#4
Independence From Malign Foreign Influence
1.00 / 1
#1
Presidential Rhetorical Leadership
1.41 / 3
#50
Outcomes
21.62 / 40
#66
Quality of Alumni Network
0.00 / 1
#29
Payback Education Investment
6.26 / 13
#99
Value Added to Career
8.61 / 16
#48
Value Added to Education
6.75 / 10
#24
Student Life
4.76 / 10
#46
Student Ideological Pluralism
1.48 / 4
#47
Student Freedom to Speak
0.70 / 1
#2
Student Political Tolerance
0.63 / 1
#77
Student Social Life
0.00 / 1
#65
Student Political Restraint
0.64 / 1
#104
ROTC Participation
0.70 / 1
#13
Student Community Life
0.60 / 1
#31