Carnegie Mellon University
Carnegie Mellon University was founded by Andrew Carnegie, the great industrialist and Scottish immigrant who rose to become one of America’s richest men. It’s not difficult to imagine how dismayed he might be by the state of his namesake institution today.
Carnegie Mellon’s administration has demonstrated a strong commitment to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives. The university has twice received the Higher Education Excellence in Diversity (HEED) award. Under federal pressure to scale back DEI programming, Carnegie Mellon has rebranded its central DEI office as the Office of the Vice Provost for Community, Culture and Engagement, though much of its diversity infrastructure remains intact. The university also operates a Center for Student Diversity and Inclusion, which supports a wide range of identity-focused programs and student groups. In 2025, the federal government launched an investigation into Carnegie Mellon, later concluding that the university had engaged in unlawful race-based discrimination.
Among all the schools that we studied, Carnegie Mellon is the second most susceptible to foreign influence, largely because of its financial ties to Qatar, where it operates a branch campus. The university has received approximately $2 billion in Qatari funding—far more than from any other foreign country—as well as $59.7 million from China and $2.9 million from Russia, both federally designated “countries of concern.”
Carnegie Mellon has a record of putting demographic diversity ahead of merit. The university filed an amicus brief supporting affirmative action in the Students for Fair Admissions case at the Supreme Court. Its current faculty job advertisements contain evidence of diversity requirements. On the other hand, Carnegie Mellon has recently moved away from test-optional admissions: beginning in fall 2026, the School of Computer Science requires the SAT or ACT, while most other programs require applicants to submit some form of standardized test results.
Carnegie Mellon has taken some steps to curb the influence of activists on the administration. In 2024, the university adopted a policy of institutional neutrality, pledging to refrain from weighing in on cultural and political flashpoints. It no longer publishes an official land acknowledgment, but ideological priorities remain apparent in other initiatives, such as the university’s formal environmental commitments.
The university’s commitment to free speech is weak. Carnegie Mellon has not endorsed the Chicago Principles, which affirm the importance of open inquiry in higher education, and it operates a bias-response system that monitors speech deemed offensive—a practice that can chill student discourse. According to the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), 68 percent of students say that, if a controversy over offensive speech were to occur, the administration would be at least somewhat likely to defend the speaker’s right to express his opinions on campus—lower than the national average of 72 percent. FIRE gives the university a “yellow” speech code rating, indicating that its policies are vulnerable to abuse and may restrict open expression.
The faculty at Carnegie Mellon skews heavily to the left. Asked to place their professors on an ideological continuum, where 1 is “very liberal” and 7 is “very conservative,” students put them at 2.4, on average. Only 3.6 percent of faculty who donate to political campaigns reliably contribute to conservative candidates or causes. A negligible share of the faculty belongs to organizations that promote academic freedom and viewpoint diversity in the classroom. However, the university does maintain a Heterodox Academy chapter, which promotes open inquiry and constructive disagreement on campus. Even so, political extremism remains a problem, and the rate of faculty-led deplatforming attempts in the past five years, according to FIRE, is about 3.5 times higher than average.
Students lean heavily left, scoring 34.9 on a political-balance scale from 0 (“homogeneous”) to 100 (“perfect balance”). Self-censorship is common: 56 percent of students tell FIRE that they censor themselves during conversations with other students on campus at least once or twice a month, compared with 59 percent nationally. Students report greater comfort expressing their opinions on campus than their peers at many schools in our rankings and are less likely than average to conceal their views from professors out of concern for their grades. This is likely the result of ideological conformity rather than independent thought.
Political tolerance is relatively higher among Carnegie Mellon students than at most schools, though students still show more willingness to bar controversial right-wing speakers from campus than left-wing ones. They are also likelier than most peers to reject disruptive protest tactics, though support for some forms of disruption remains high: 66 percent of students tell FIRE it is acceptable to shout down a speaker, at least in rare cases. Only 21 percent say that violence can be an acceptable response to speech, compared with 34 percent nationally.
Carnegie Mellon’s curriculum is weak. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) gives the university a D in its What Will They Learn? ratings, which assign letter grades based on how many of seven core subjects are required in the core curriculum or general education program. The university does not require students to take courses in history or government, though they are not required to complete DEI-focused coursework, either. Only 21.7 percent of the history faculty pursue research related to critical theory concepts, compared with an average of 34 percent. History course descriptions using progressive terminology outnumber those referencing the traditional canon by 3.9 to 1.
The university earns ninth place in our rankings for its strong academic and economic outcomes. Six-year graduation and retention rates are both higher than average and exceed predictions based on student SAT scores and Pell Grant eligibility. Financial returns are impressive. Median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment approach $114,900—one of the five highest figures in our rankings, exceeding the norm by approximately $33,900 and overperforming expectations by about $28,800. Graduates typically take 1.8 years to recoup the cost of a Carnegie Mellon education, faster than our average repayment period of 2.5 years.